Shay Mitchell & Ashley Benson Make JJ's Halloween Party More 'Pretty': Photo 887447 | 2015 Halloween, 2015 Just Jared Halloween Party, Ashley Benson, Janel Parrish, Nathalia Ramos, Shay Mitchell, Skyler Shaye Pictures | Just Jared Jr.
Ashley Benson Wears Unfortunate Halloween Costume, People Disapprove
Celebrity Halloween Costumes That Sparked Controversy